A recent investigation spearheaded by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists has exposed the chilling lack of accountability of the medical devices industry.
The sad state of affairs in India –
- In the Indian context, the findings expose the nexus between implant makers, health finance players and doctors, as they chase targets at the expense of vulnerable, unsuspecting patients.
- Quality lapses are not readily accounted for (be it knee implants, hip implants, pacemakers or intra-uterine devices) because for patients, there is no clear agency to deal with such situations.
- With surgeries being performed, as the investigation, in “basement operating theatres of DDA flats”, it is clear that the regulatory system has failed.
Need for regulation –
- For an industry that is valued in India at $5.2 billion and is growing at 16 per cent annually, with imports accounting for 80 per cent of all sales, this is a grim state of affairs.
- The wrangling over compensation continues because there are no clear norms laid down under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 and the Medical Devices Rules, 2017 for such eventualities.
- In the case of Johnsons & Johnsons, India’s drugs regulator was slow to react to the global recall and establish the extent of damage.
Regulatory failures –
The regulatory failure is evident at various levels –
- in the testing of the implants;
- in informing the patient of the consequences and making her aware of her rights; and
- in the compensation mechanism.
What needs to be done?
- The Medical Devices Rules, 2017 may be modified to include compensation aspects, with a committee looking into the issue.
- So far, compensation sums have been arrived at on the basis of damages laid down in clinical trial regulations. This is inappropriate, as a patient or individual who submits herself to clinical trials cannot be equated with one who actually needs an implant and opts for a trusted product.
- The rules rightly categorise devices into various categories of risk and spell out regulatory requirements for each. However, over-reliance on certification from the US, EU or Japan for imported products may require to be reviewed.
There can be no getting away from double standards in compensation for Indian lives lost in medical tragedies. We need to raise the costs for those who are playing with the lives of our citizens.
Source – The Hindu Business Line
We provide quality UPSC Coaching in Chandigarh. For all your queries regarding the class structure, material and mentorship for our programmes concerned with PCS Coaching in Chandigarh, HCS Coaching in Chandigarh and similar civil services coaching in Chandigarh region and beyond, you can contact us directly at Raj IAS Academy to avail professional quality IAS Coaching in Chandigarh. Raj IAS Academy wishes you all the best for your preparation.